Navigating the New Frontier: Private Equity and the HVAC/R Industry

Introduction

The commercial HVAC/R industry is transforming significantly as private equity firms increasingly target this once-stable sector. Traditionally run by founder-led, small businesses, the industry is now seeing private equity (PE) firms swoop in, reshaping operations and fueling expansion. As this evolution unfolds, it prompts important questions: How will these changes impact the industry, the founders, and—most importantly—the customers? In this blog post, we’ll explore how the HVAC/R industry is evolving, the impact of private equity, and how TCG’s unique approach—leveraging data, analytics, and exceptional service—stands out in the competitive multi-site facilities landscape, allowing us to offer superior customer care.

Private Equity: A Double-Edged Sword

Private equity has been a double-edged sword for many HVAC/R companies. As highlighted in Te-Ping Chen’s Wall Street Journal article, America’s New Millionaire Class: Plumbers and HVAC Entrepreneurs, private equity has provided many small business owners with life-changing financial windfalls. Entrepreneurs who sell their private equity-backed firms often benefit from larger-scale operations and expanded resources. However, many, even after scaling, face the challenge of balancing growth with preserving the core values that made their business successful in the first place. 

While private equity offers the financial means to scale operations, invest in new technologies, and expand customer reach, it’s crucial to distinguish between transactional relationships and genuine partnerships. Customers may wonder whether this type of investment prioritizes service quality or simply focuses on quick profits. Understanding this distinction is paramount to avoiding the “one-size-fits-all” mentality that often accompanies large-scale acquisitions.

The Roll-Up Phenomenon

One of the most prevalent strategies in this evolving landscape is the “roll-up” model, where PE-backed firms acquire and merge multiple companies under a single umbrella. 

For customers, the big question is whether these roll-ups will maintain the level of service, capabilities, and trust they’ve come to expect. As firms scale up, there’s a risk that smaller, local businesses will lose the intimate connection they had with their communities, leaving customers to feel like “just another number.”

However, Total Comfort Group (TCG) takes a different approach. As a value-driven, privately held business, TCG can maintain its commitment to personalized service, ensuring that every customer’s needs are met with the same care and attention that helped the company grow. TCG’s model prioritizes building lasting relationships, rather than focusing solely on growth or cost-cutting measures, allowing our company to offer a level of customer service that our large, VC-backed competitors simply can’t match. 

Quality vs. Quantity: The Service Dilemma

In the race to boost top-line revenue, some HVAC/R companies may overextend themselves, leading to stretched resources and slower response times. Going back to Chen’s WSJ article, it includes that while private equity backing can lead to improved services and higher technician pay, it can also put pressure on technicians to upsell new systems, sometimes at the expense of simply repairing what’s broken.

Unlike many large, PE-backed providers that prioritize growth at all costs, TCG leverages data-driven insights to enhance the expertise and satisfaction of its customers. By using analytics to support informed decision-making, TCG empowers facility managers to better control expenses, anticipate upcoming repairs, and maintain efficient operations. The company’s structure enables TCG to remain involved in the day-to-day operations of multi-site facilities across the nation, ensuring white-glove services tailored to customers’ specific needs, without pushing unnecessary products or services. 

For customers, this raises a valid concern: Will the company still be responsive to your specific needs, or will it prioritize higher revenue at the expense of quality service? The key lies in choosing companies that balance growth with a continued commitment to customer satisfaction. 

Diversification and Stability

Private-equity investment often enables companies to diversify their services, such as expanding from HVAC/R into plumbing and electrical work after they are acquired. While this diversification can provide stability and shield businesses from market fluctuation, it sometimes comes at the expense of the personalized service that customers have come to expect. 

In contrast, privately held companies like TCG are expanding strategically while maintaining their commitment to personalized service. By thoughtfully adding valuable services and expertise to their portfolio, they ensure that customer care remains at the forefront, delivering customized solutions without losing the personal touch that sets them apart. 

The Skilled Labor Crisis

One of the most significant challenges facing the HVAC/R industry is the ongoing skilled labor shortage. As noted in the WSJ article, private equity-backed companies are uniquely positioned to tackle this issue through investments in apprenticeship programs and technician training. However, for customers, it’s important to consider not just the size of a company but the quality and expertise of the technicians they employ. 

Maintaining high service standards in an industry where the demand for skilled workers exceeds supply requires more than just an investment – it demands a commitment to quality and expertise. TCG stands out in this regard, with leadership deeply invested in training its technicians and ensuring a hands-on approach to every aspect of service delivery. Known for consistently achieving an impressive 70% first-time fix rate, TCG distinguishes itself through its commitment to cultivating and hiring highly skilled, master-level technicians. By prioritizing attention to detail, data analytics, and personalized service, TCG continues to earn the trust of its customers. This dedication sets TCG apart from the larger, VC-backed competitors that may offer lower prices but fail to match its exceptional standards, data-centric tracking systems, and customer-first approach. 

Partnerships Over Transactions

A true partnership between private equity and HVAC/R companies goes beyond financial transactions. As highlighted in Chen’s article, the trades are increasingly recognized as a legitimate path to wealth creation, with many entrepreneurs receiving life-changing financial offers for their businesses. However, for this relationship to benefit customers, long-term growth and quality service must be prioritized over short-term profits. 

At TCG, we often hear from customers who have tried working with competitors acquired by large PE-backed firms, only to feel let down by declining service quality and impersonal interactions. These customers come to TCG seeking something different—a return to dependable, personalized service delivered with integrity and expertise. Unlike firms focused solely on scaling rapidly, TCG maintains its commitment to white-glove care, ensuring every customer receives tailored solutions designed to meet their unique needs.

By prioritizing quality over quantity, TCG builds lasting relationships that stand in stark contrast to the transactional nature of many VC-backed competitors. This approach reinforces that true partnerships aren’t just about financial growth—they’re about delivering value and trust to the customers who rely on us every day.

The TCG Advantage: Prioritizing Legacy and Core Values

In contrast to the rapid scaling approach of many VC-backed entities, selling to privately held companies like TCG offers a unique and compelling alternative. This was recently exemplified by TCG’s acquisition of Victor’s Air Conditioning Company, Inc., a family-run business with a deep-rooted reputation in Central New Jersey since 1965. Rather than overhauling the company, TCG is focused on taking Victor’s strengths and building upon them, preserving the essence and values that made it successful for nearly six decades.

By partnering with TCG, family-built businesses gain the resources to expand and retain the personalized service and core values that define their legacy. As TCG integrates Victor’s into its larger operations, it upholds a model of sustainable growth that respects both employees and customers. This approach demonstrates a way forward in which growth and values are not mutually exclusive, setting a valuable precedent for customers seeking high-quality, trustworthy service in a rapidly evolving industry landscape. 

Conclusion

As private equity continues to shape the future of the HVAC/R industry, facility managers should look for companies that balance growth with the values that made them successful in the first place. While many PE-backed firms pursue rapid expansion at the cost of customer service, TCG’s independent approach allows it to grow without losing sight of the white-glove service and personalized care that has earned it a loyal customer base.

The right balance between financial growth and customer care will be key in ensuring that this transformation benefits not just the business owners and investors but also the customers who rely on these vital services. As Chen’s article highlights, the trades offer entrepreneurial opportunities that may not have existed a decade ago. Still, the success of these ventures will ultimately depend on how well they continue to serve the people at the heart of the business.

By sticking to its core values and prioritizing strong, genuine relationships with customers, TCG is setting a new precedent in the industry—one that proves you don’t need to jump on the PE bandwagon to scale successfully. Instead, you can grow at a sustainable pace while maintaining the quality of service that customers expect and deserve.

Are you interested in learning more about our acquisition process? Connect with us today.